Sunday, April 9, 2017

ZUMA PLUNGES SOUTH AFRICA INTO A FINANCIAL CRISIS .





As Donald Trump’s woes inexorably grind on, in Southern Africa another drama is rapidly unfolding which too holds the fate of a Presidency. What both Presidential sagas appear to have in common are the drummers that they are marching to have very little interest in the well being of their respective countries. Trump appears to have colluded with the Russians to destroy American democracy and weaken its NATO Alliance while Jacob Zuma, it is argued, is selling out the South African economy to meet the needs of himself and three shady brothers who have a stranglehold on him. Trump’s future depends on what a few Republicans in the Senate might decide and or whether the 2018 midterm elections will show enough disillusionment in him to cut loose his support. Zuma has a healthier back up as he has inherited the party of Mandela, the African National Congress, (ANC), with it a fat legislative majority. He is relying on the fact that enough of them are too beholden to him to switch allegiance. Seventy votes need to abandon ship for a vote of no confidence to succeed. The latter would bring down the Zuma Government.

South Africa with all its wealth and promise is getting closer and closer to midnight as the erratic behaviour of the President careers on.

WHAT PRECIPITATED THE CRISIS

Zuma precipitated a major economic crisis with his recent decision to sack five cabinet ministers and six deputy ministers. The crucial axing was of his Finance Minister Gordhan and his Deputy. Zuma has desperately been trying to control his treasury for some time and has been through this exercise before when he terminated his then Minister of Finance, Nene, in December 2015. Like this time the action caused a run on the South African currency - the Rand. The latter in spite of reported Reserve Bank support has lost ten percent in a few days. On the first occasion Zuma recanted within days and appointed Gordhan as Finance Minister who he has now given the chop. This time his decision is for good.

The beleaguered President has made it quite clear that he is not going back even though Standard and Poor and Fitch have responded to his decision by downgrading South African bonds to junk status. Moodie’s rating group have put South Africa on notice in that they have three months to get their act in order. Zuma has thus signalled that he is prepared to live or die by this cabinet switch barefacedly giving inane reasons for it. Where he differs from The Donald is that is where his explanations end. There are no inane tweets or pathetic pleas of victimization. This is his Constitutional right and that is that.

THE STORY BEHIND IT ALL

The South African media - formal and social has been awash for years over the influence a family have had over Zuma. The Guptas are said to run the country to the extent that individuals are offered Cabinet posts by them. The oft repeated claim is that Zuma and his cabal are in the Guptas’ pockets. Currently the Guptas’ bank accounts have been suspended by the four major banks in South Africa who have claimed that their financial dealings have been “reckless”. At the time of Gordhan’s departure there was ongoing litigation between him and the Guptas’ who wanted to force the then Finance Minister to intercede with the recalcitrant banks on their behalf.

Besides all the stories of graft, cronyism and corruption that have plagued Zuma’s administration there are two major expenditures that Gordhan’s Treasury would not accede to. These are the purchase of aeroplanes and most importantly the creation of three nuclear plants with good old Putin’s Russia. The latter deal runs into billions of dollars and would devastate the country’s economy. The social media buzz is that there are astronomically fat commissions involved.

THE LINE UP AGAINST ZUMA.

The opposition against Zuma is growing exponentially by the day. However, like all democratic politics, change boils down to simple math. You have to have more votes where it matters and in this instance it is Parliament. About seventy ANC members need to switch. There are a number of highly influential power blocks that have come out against the rogue President as well as religious groups, non - governmental agencies and activist societies. But actually getting shot of him is a very tall order.

The Founding Fathers of the New South Africa.

Whatever old guard Mandela support Zuma might have had has publicly vanished. As it so happened the week of the long knifes saw the death of one of Mandela’s life long cadres and friends, Mohammed Kathrada.  The latter spent all twenty - six years as Mandela’s cell mate, was in his government and remained a close friend and confidant. Everyone loved Kathy who was regarded as a gentle soul. Just prior to his death he had written Zuma a very public letter telling him to step down for the good of the country. Kathrada also left instructions that he didn’t want the South African President at his funeral. The former interim South African President Molantehe eulogized the old ANC warrior and read this letter at his funeral.

 Anyone who was anyone in “the struggle” formerly assembled in front of TV cameras and berated Zuma for his disrespect to Kathrada’s memory and neglect of his widow who also served ten years prison time. This constituency – the fathers and mothers of the nation still are held in the highest esteem but none of them have any of the seventy votes needed.

Mandela the great conciliator formed his government with two other major groups who were instrumental in change – the Communist Party of South Africa, (CPSA), and the trade group organization COSATU.

The other alliance members – COSATU and the CPSA

COSATU, which was in the forefront of the struggle within South Africa at the time of the apartheid breakdown, has roundly condemned Zuma. He did not consult them as the original terms of the alliance dictated. The special meeting on the crisis had no qualms in blurting out that Zuma’s motives were not in the best interests of the country. In his cabinet reshuffle they claim he kept incompetents as well as appointing a few more. The CPSA who are in this triumvirate for historical reasons as during the dark decades of apartheid it was the old USSR that backed the ANC while the West acquiesced with the repressive apartheid regime, They sailed into Zuma for betraying the revolution. Between the two groups much sound and fury but few votes.

The Governing ANC.

At the time of Zuma’s midnight coup the ANC appeared divided on the wily President. Three of the six most powerful members of the party were publicly against the President. Most notable of these was Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa and the ANC Secretary General, Mantasche. The ANC executive are technically a very powerful constituency in the running of the Government. This fact coupled with the fact that several ANC branches have criticized the President and the important ANC Integrity Committee had censored him lead pundits to believe that the impossible might happen – Zuma’s ouster. However after a hastily convened meeting “all the good men rallied round the party”, withdrew their objections and stood united as to what was now defined as an opposition attack on the ANC. The sop that Zuma appeared to throw them would be that the South African energy policy, (a.k.a. nuclear reactors), would proceed at a pace in sync with its needs.

There is growing disillusionment with Cyril Ramaphosa who was once a firebrand in COSATU. Greatly admired by Mandela he was the latter’s choice as his successor. After that defeat he turned into a capitalist deluxe and he is credited as being the richest politician in South Africa. That being no mean feat with the competition around. He was elected as Deputy Premier at the last ANC Convention and has been the hope of the sane. This was the first time he has made a move and in reality, if he was serious at thwarting a Zuma appointed successor in 2018, he had to project an alternative vision. 

Slowly gaining prominence is the ousted Finance Minister Gordhan. He is still a prominent ANC member and his popularity makes it difficult for Zuma to frame him as he attempted to do. The latter claimed that he had an intelligence report that Gordhan and his Deputy were about to sell the country down the river. The ANC Executive rejected that outright in their support of Zuma rather conceding that he had the right to axe Gordhan as he could not relate to him. The elephant in the room in a possible Presidential bid is that Gordhan is of Indian rather than of African origin and as such, in this polarized environment, is unlikely to mount a serious challenge.

However he is the focus within the Party at present articulating the ground roots dissatisfaction. He has roundly condemned incompetence of a Cabinet Minister who nearly left millions without their meagre monthly grants. He also makes no bones that the Guptas run the show pointing to an instance where they offered an ANC member a cabinet position and hundreds of thousands of rands.  

The ANC face serious problems as they are losing support at every turn. At the last municipal election they lost Mayorships in nearly every major city in South Africa.    
      
The Official Opposition

The official opposition is made up of the Democratic Alliance, (DA), which still has a lingering “white” image. They were not helped by recent statements by its former white leader and now Premier of the Western Cape which Province the DA controls. Helen Zillie, who is a remarkably efficient administrator and a revered pioneer of opposition against apartheid, tweeted that everything colonialism did was not all bad. In the current South African political context such a remark is akin to claiming, in America, that slavery was not all that bad.

The ANC pounced on this smearing Zillie as being a paternalistic white saviour. The ANC media led with the Zillie story while Zuma was burning. The DA has responded by dragging the Cape Premier before a disciplinary committee. They are making a serious attempt to gain disaffected ANC supporters and don’t need any reminders that the midwifes of their Party were white. In fairness to the DA their black Africa backing has grown by leaps and bounds in the past few years.

The quixotic Economic Freedom Party, (EEF), a populist Leninist organization completes the opposition. They only represent nine percent of the electorate. They have combined with the DA when it comes to opposing Zuma’s ANC.  Led by an exhibitionist, Julius Malema, they are not taken seriously at the moment.

Suffice to say the motion of no confidence the opposition have proposed is chanceless without ANC support.

Mass Protest   

Friday April 7 was declared a national protest day against Zuma and gatherings were held throughout the country. It was the largest display of public discontent on record. Businesses backed the outpouring of anger with well over half giving their workers paid leave to join in. The upshot is unlikely to sway any of the Parliament’s decision makers which will just add to the general discontent.

THE UPSHOT

Whatever the outcome of the protests South Africa has taken another plunge into banana republic status. Zuma is not going to back off and like Mugabe of Zimbabwe he couldn’t care less what the impact of his perfidy is. Inflation of the currency has little impact on the wealth of those that garner the lion share of money. Nor do the protesters have any votes in the Parliament. 

The massive, broad sweeping national response to Zuma has to have an impact somewhere. Most likely it will weaken Zuma’s hand at appointing a successor as he is curtailed from a future run by term limits. Also the DA have gone into election mode for the 2019 elections already. They appear well organized and funded and are poised to capitalize on their gains made in the recent municipal elections. Ironically they more resemble Mandela’s rainbow nation than do the ANC.

The fact that Pravin Gordhan has not resigned his Parliamentary seat spells trouble for the ANC. He is served notice that he will participate in the No Confidence debate and obviously will vote against Zuma. The ANC will have no alternative other than to throw him out and with him expect a big defection.

All this has brought about murmurings of emigration amongst the minorities. While the ANC radicals will claim good riddance to bad rubbish it cannot be good news. For whatever reason they believe that wealth, know how, skills and tertiary education will magically, automatically be transferred immediately.

PAUSE FOR THOUGHT.

One characteristic both Zuma and Trump have is – they both have no shame! 



Wednesday, March 22, 2017

TRUMP: THE UNRAVELING CONTINUES.






This last week saw further far reaching revelations of the Russian interference into the American way of life which fairly and squarely were placed at the door of Trump and his campaign team of Russian operatives. Paul Manafort, former Trump Campaign Manager and the man credited with guiding him into and through the Republican nomination process, being the latest to be found to be knee deep in Russian collusion.  The Republican legislators’ negative responses to the Trump Whitehouse revelations prompted The Donald to counter with his usual bizarre diversionary tactics and “alternative truths” which have thus far sustained him in his brief sojourn into the political world. 

While only sixty days into his term Trump’s faced a new variable - open defiance, at the highest levels from Republican leaders. The latter, in the face of incontrovertible evidence contradicting his questionable behavior towards Obama coupled with pressure from their constituents, reluctantly abandoned their rock solid unconditional backing of the POTUS. His erratic behavior has resulted in the topic of impeachment being discussed more and more.

All this was a backdrop to FBI Director Comey officially negating Trump’s bizarre allegations of Obama wiretapping Trump Tower. He also dramatically confirmed the fact that the current investigation of the Russian illegal intervention into America’s Presidential election included whether there was any criminal collusion between the Trump campaign and Putin. 

 THE CENTRAL ISSUES

Front and central to the Donald’s woes is the Russian connection. Every day brings forth another sordid saga of his or his team’s involvement with America’s despotic adversary, Russia and its dictator Putin. The recent bohaai occasioned by the exposure of his chief political ally, Attorney General Jeff Sessions, lying about encounters with the Russian Ambassador created first a national then an international crisis. His diversion to the Sessions cause celeb was to accuse President Obama of personally ordering a wiretapping on him and Trump Tower. When that was treated as the theater of the absurd he blamed the British spy agency for the eavesdropping. More recently he stuck to his delusional guns by involving a bemused Angela Merkel into the conspiracy. The completion of the trifecta of his major woes resulted from him jumping, boots and all, to support the Republican’s new health care plan “Ryancare”. The latter an ill thought out amoral repeal and replacement of “Obamacare” was then labelled “Trumpcare”.

TRUMP’S  MANAGERIAL PROBLEM

Trump still hasn’t adjusted from the CEO mode to political leadership management. It is one skill surrounding yourself with loyal unquestioning and obedient nonentities which he has done all his life – it is another to collaborate and compromise with a slew of independent political legislators whose authority is not dependent on his patronage. Added to this inconvenience is his inability to dictate to the middle management bureaucracies that run the various governmental departments. It is a piece of cake to out manoeuvre the “dishonest fake press” and turn all publicity into a triumph. It is another challenge to bully and cajole legislators whose pay checks he does not sign and whose jobs are dependent on their constituents.

In short investigations have been initiated into “his business” that he has no control over other than to try and influence the participants, most of whom he has abused. For the first time in his seventy years he cannot call on his father to bail him out or bully, bullshit, bluff and bluster with a team of lawyers to frustrate his opponents. His mentor was Roy Cohn, Eugene McCarthy’s lawyer who taught him never to apologize and to respond by double downing on the ante when challenged.

TRUMP’S DEFENSES.

In addition to tweets, refusing to answer questions and doubling down, he can and does return to his hero worshiping, strident and angry following who swoon, froth at the mouth and cheer every populist statement he utters. Then there are the neophyte loyalist sycophants that he surrounds himself with who provide implausible explanations and rationalizations for his tripe. His diversionary tactics are well known where he focuses attention away from an uncomfortable subject by some outlandish accusation or remark.

A common approach of his is the alternative facts production and interpretation of statistics a la Trump mode. For example, candidate Trump claimed you could not trust the Labor Department statistics. He exclaimed when “they” say there is five percent unemployment it can really be up to forty two percent. He now agrees with the Labor Department numbers, claiming credit for them and his sycophants think it is one big joke. Another bizarre diversionary tactic was said to be in the form of an anonymous leak of two pages of his 2005 tax returns that provided little of the detail demanded as to his business affairs. In fact the leak reflected on him favorably. He commented on the tax forms before the media did leading the recipient of the forms, a famous Trump biographer, to allege that it was Trump that leaked them.    

In short he creates a new reality and the question is to how this can help him in his current predicament.

WHAT IS HAPPENING NOW?

Currently both Houses of Congress have ongoing investigations into Russia and Trump's involvement and his allegation that Obama wiretapped his campaign. There are also statutory investigations by bodies such as the FBI.  In addition Trump is conducting a full press support of the Republican effort to remove and replace Obamacare. With regard to the alleged Obama wiretap both Republican controlled committees have taken the unprecedented step to accept that no evidence exists to back these claims.

The big elephant in the Trump Whitehouse is the Russian 
connection. On its face the situation for Trump is pretty serious. 
To start with Russia is America’s adversary and
currently the USA have sanctions in place against it.  (Sanctions which the Republicans don’t think are strong enough). It has been  confirmed by Comey– Russia intervened in the American Presidential election in favour of Trump’s candidacy. The campaign was strewn with Trump’s professed love and admiration for Putin at the expense of America’s NATO allies. Several of Trump’s campaign were involved with Russian operatives. The issue now remains as to whether Trump and or his organization criminally colluded with Russia.

It is common knowledge that the FBI have in their possession a report from a former British spy agent that alleges collusion. Some of that report has already proved true. Just to quote one item in the report where the Russian sources claim that Trump would soften the Republican election Platform on Russia as a quid pro quo. At the Republican Conference it is alleged that a Russian operative was negotiating the deal. Trump surprisingly only wanted one change to the Republican election platform, namely softening the position on Russia.  One of the Trump team J. D. Gordon stated that he was responsible for the pro Russian amendments which he executed on Trump’s instructions.  

The Russian story is thus pretty serious stuff.

 HOW LONG CAN TRUMP SURVIVE? WHAT HAPPENED TO NIXON AND CLINTON?

 The question that everyone is asking, in private, is how long can this go on for? How can Trump be axed? The term impeachment is loosely bandied about in these conversations . What will it take to impeach? In short it will take a helluva lot but Trump is a champ and a first at everything - “believe me”. Impeachment proceedings have been started three times in USA history and each time the President and Congress were in different political parties. 

 The most successful effort in living memory at removing a President was the impeachment of Richard Nixon. The Nixon episode  provides a clue as to the overwhelming effort it takes to remove a President. The impeachment of Bill Clinton was a hopelessly partisan affair and was doomed to failure from the word go. It did not get one Democratic legislator in support. In fact Clinton’s approval rating were at a peak during and after  the Republican effort to unseat him.

 So using the Nixon and Clinton precedents let us go ahead with “The Fool’s Guide to Impeach the POTUS”. The Nixon process was painfully slow, transparent with public hearings both in the Senate and the House. Justice was seen to be done. Like the Trump situation there was aggressive media investigation and reporting. Then there were leaks galore. Famously there was the deputy head of the FBI,“Deep Throat”, who tipped off iconic Washington Post reporters Woodward and Bernstein. The two Democratic Chairman of the investigative committees in the Senate and the House were at pains to involve the Republicans in the process so that when push came to shove it was a bipartisan effort. Eventually the minority Republican leaders together with party stalwart Barry Goldwater approached the paranoid Nixon to tell him they never had the votes to prevent impeachment and his eventual dismissal. The subtle process was orchestrated by Chief of Staff Alexander Haig who understood the need for the succession of power to be as smooth as possible. The body politic, unlike the Clinton effort, was totally onside with the process. 

 At the moment the Republican leadership are nowhere ready to take the plunge. If anything they are in diversionary mode. They are waiting for Comey to produce the goods and then maybe…. The media are daily making exposures and just maybe beginning to indent Trump’s support. While his approval rate has dropped from forty eight percent to forty two percent it has been solid. However, if the rebellion in Republican constituencies is anything to go by and “Trump/RyanCare” cannot pass because it has been exposed for the fraud that it is there has to be a danger of losing the House in 2018. The coal miners are not back in the mines, manufacturing jobs have not materialized and his budget does not help the one hundred thousand or so workers that switched to give him the electoral college victory. These factors can well end the Republican reign. There is a hope, if the evidence becomes so overwhelming, that the GOP in a desire to avoid an electoral defeat move for impeachment. Also the antipathy towards Russia by the whole Congress cannot be underestimated. The GOP too are furious at the Russian act of war at interfering in their democracy. If Trump can be conclusively shown to have colluded with Putin there are a number that will put country before party.

 There is another mechanism whereby Trump could be terminated in terms of the 25th Amendment to the Constitution. Here the Vice President and the Cabinet have to deem the President incapable to carry out his duties. There is abundant credible psychiatric evidence emerging daily where literally hundreds of professionals have made diagnoses ranging from narcissistic personality, sociopath, and even delusional and psychotic. However, short of Trump going raving nuts - nothing is going to happen. There is a hope, if the evidence becomes so overwhelming, that the GOP in a desire to avoid an electoral defeat move for impeachment before the 1918 elections. 
 
AT THE END OF THE DAY The noose has to be tightening. The FBI Director has announced that he is conducting a criminal investigation into Trump and his campaign to see if there is any evidence of criminal collusion with the Russians. The Trump campaign have responded by throwing Mike Flynn and Paul Manafort under the bus. That is what Nixon did in the slow process of his dying reign.

 The biggest irony is that Trump trumpets his strong armed tactics
as his main attribute. He, the man whose campaign is being
investigated for what amounts to treason, is the guy to rely on to
keep the country safe. Look what has just happened
in London he is about to scream! Trump may reflect that had the
perpetrator had First Amendment Rights, which he so ardently
champions, there would have been more than four dead.

Friday, March 10, 2017

TRUMP/RYANCARE D. 0. A.?









The rubber has hit the road. Populist Trump, has to deliver on his promise to make health care more affordable and available to everyone while repealing the “disastrous Obamacare”. That has to be effected while, simultaneously, ensuring the passage of a health care act acceptable to the Republican legislature. The disunited GOP, which up till now has been able to paper over its vast divisions, has to cobble together legislation that the differing philosophical wings agree to in order to “repeal and replace”.

 As Jay H. Ell has blogged repeatedly, notwithstanding the across the board Republican victories, the Party is far less united than the Democratic Party. The latter are expected to vote en bloc against any Republican proposal. As matters stand there are Republican legislators that are totally against any subsidized health care while there are those that want to hang onto at least the current number insured or even increase the numbers.  Unless a miracle happens the Ryan’s bill, the American Health Care Act, (AHCA), which currently pleases neither Republican faction, is  D. O. A - dead on arrival. Even if it passes the House the Senate objectors seem immutable.

America, like health care, is “very complicated”. There are major constituencies and interest groups that impact a decision of this nature. Obama with all his majorities and a clear mandate ended up with a bastardized plan after eight months of negotiation and compromise. Trump promised an improvement on the status quo and whether the Republican legislators like it or not, implicit in their repeal and replace mantra there is an expectation from the electorate for more health care not less.

So the players are;  the electorate, the Governors of States, the Legislature, the Institutions and Pressure Groups and finally the POTUS himself. But before examining their input the plan itself needs explanation.

THE PLAN AS IT STANDS.

There are two components repeal and replace Obamacare or Affordable Health Act, (ACA). The repeal is easy and the GOP have done the latter sixty times in the Obama era when they never had the responsibility to replace it. If the Conservatives in the GOP had their way that is all that they would do. However, that would negate election promises which in one way or another promised to replace it with something “better”. 

Well, instead, the new plan gets rid of the component that extends Medicaid, the insurance for the poor. It eliminates the monetary subsidies and replaces them with tax credits, for those with lower incomes that don’t qualify for Medicaid. These credits are a complicated process to collect and don’t provide the cash there and then to pay. The analysis is that the whole maneuver will ensure drop outs from insurance cover. Then these tax concessions are based on age rather than income, disadvantaging those with lower incomes. However, the AHCA allows for seniors to be charged up to five times as much as compared to the youth by insurers. The mandate for everyone to enroll is removed so the healthy young will opt out thereby placing a greater onus on the seniors to cover the whole burden, therefore risking skyrocketing premiums. The tax on the rich associated with the Affordable Care Act, (ACA), has been removed so the rich benefit decidedly by the new dispensation.

The Ryan effort lays the ground work to axe Planned Parenthood the organization that provides reproductive health services and other primary care services in six hundred and fifty clinics across the country. It serves close on three million patients and in 2014 performed nearly ten million individual services. The money that it receives from the Government is in return for Medicaid interactions and is not a straight grant. The reason for the anger, which will throw an already dysfunctional health system into greater disarray, is that Planned Parenthood provides abortion services in 3% of it’s clinical activities.

The good news is that the Ryan plan still mandates insurance companies to not exclude patients on the basis of pre existing conditions and still allows children up to the age of twenty six to remain on their parents plans.  Even better news for the Republicans is that the AHCA  is programmed to come into effect in 2020 so that it is unlikely to impact the mid term and the 2020 Presidential election.

THE ELECTORATE AND THE GOVERNORS OF THE STATES:

The recent congressional recess saw pandemonium at the Republican town hall meetings at the threat of removing “Obamacare”. The message was loud and clear - Don’t touch what we have already. The number that are covered to date as a result of Obama’s Affordable Care Act, (ACA), is twenty - million.  The enrollment for 2017 shot up dramatically to six and a half million. The recruitment number is far more than last year which fact has to be indicative that many believe this is their last chance for coverage. 

The Obama ACA increased coverage by two methods - by increasing the pool of Americans eligible for Medicaid which is the entitlement program for those in the lowest income bracket and by creating a program whereby those without insurance could gain acceptance. Some of those lower income groups who didn’t qualify for Medicaid received subsidies. This  was especially attractive for those with preexisting conditions, who previously were excluded from insurance.  With regard to the Medicaid expansion program, thirty - two of the fifty states adapted it. (Some of the eighteen that didn’t are having serious second thoughts on the matter). Several of the States that signed on are Republican controlled. Most significantly the key rust belt States, that swung the Electoral College to Trump, participate. The majority of angry whites who had lost manufacturing and mining jobs are recipients of Obamacare. (Remember they were voting for a replacement that was bigger and better). 

It is obvious where the Dem Governors stand but they have Republican bed fellows. The ACA dished out nearly a hundred billion to the participating States and the Republican Governors still want their share. In addition they don’t want the flack from those that will either lose coverage or pay more for it. John Kasich of Ohio, a crucial State in the populist’s surprise victory, has lead the charge not to alter the status quo. Kasich has advocated that the GOP cooperate with the Democrats to improve Obamacare. Now the Congressional legislators in the affected States also need to give the issue one long hard look and some already have. Senators from Ohio, West Virginia, Alaska, Colorado and Maine have already have signaled that they are not on board. Added to the State opposition a hundred and thirty mayors have signed a letter to register their concerns on the repeal of the ACA.

CONSTITUENCIES WITHIN THE GOP LEGISLATURE

The Congress is the first problem for Ryan’s legislation. The AHCA is ostensibly a compromise between the two viewpoints - repeal and don’t replace and repeal and replace with “something”. Remember there are two mechanisms whereby Americans have obtained insurance under the ACA - Medicaid expansion and the newly created pools for individuals. The proposed legislation faces the biggest challenge in the Senate where there are fixed opinions on both sides of the Republican divide. There are at least five GOP Senators that won’t truck a plan that excludes the Medicaid Extension Plan and a similar number who want no replacement entitlement component whatsoever. There are reports that potentially there are up to twenty Republican Senators that for different reasons might vote against the Ryan plan or what Senator Schumer calls “Trumpcare”. Only three Republicans need to switch to defeat the Bill. Even if the bill survives the House, as matters stand at the moment it would take a major shift in positions for it to pass the Senate.

The House of Representatives most vocal opponents are those that were elected under the Tea Party banner. They now refer to themselves as the Freedom Caucus. These are not exactly middle of the road players open to compromise. Their position is that there should be no entitlement component, period. There are forty of them and they generally move as a pack. There are several other Congressmen who object to the Bill as it stands, a few of them objecting to the loss of coverage. It is not for nothing that Ryan labels his effort as “conservative” as that is the constituency he has to convince to go with him to hustle this through the House. Twenty House Republicans voting against are enough to kibosh the whole venture.

According to Fox News the non partisan Congressional Budget Office analysis has declared the AHCA more expensive and will cover fewer. Fox stated that their sources believed that this will make Ryan’s and Trump’s task that much harder. The Secretary of Health Tom Price has attempted to reassure by claiming the draft bill can be amended -“It is a work in progress”. The Brooking’s Institute’s projections are that with the AHCA fifteen of the twenty  - million who gained insurance on the ACA will lose it within ten years.

THE INSTITUTIONS AND PRESSURE GROUPS.

The Republican conservative think tanks have been unequivocal in condemning the plan as a sell out. Terms like Obamacare Light have been bandied about to characterize the offering. The influential Heritage Foundation labelled the AHCA, Obamacare 2, bad politics and bad policy. The Club for Growth have sarcastically dubbed the effort “Ryancare”. Joe Antos of the American Institute, the Cato Institute as well as The Tea Party Patriots slammed the operation claiming that the Republicans are reneging on their commitment for full repeal of Obamacare. The influential mega donors, The Koch Brothers, who have literally poured tens of billions of dollars into electing candidates so that this day would arrive, are screaming fowl.

The real pressure groups who can line up citizen votes are basically on the “adequate replacement” side of the divide. The American Association of Retired Persons who have a membership of nearly forty million have unequivocally panned the new health care act. They maintain that senior citizens come out very badly especially as the insurance companies have been given the green light to charge fees up to five times more than the young subscribers. To add insult to injury the elderly tax credits are relatively far less than their younger counterparts.The American Hospital Association say that with the reduction of Medicaid enrollees they will be providing more free care. They claim that rural hospitals are at risk and may have to close as most are barely covering costs at the moment. The American Medical Association, (doctors), and the American Nursing Association have expressed alarm and have declined to support the prospective legislation on the basis that it would result in the decline in insurance coverage and the harm it would cause to the most vulnerable populations.  The celebrated Kaiser Foundation medical think tank have added its findings to the mass of research that indicates a negative impact on health care. The  American Medical Insurance Association objections to the AHCA leaves the Ryan/Trump endeavor with no organized medical administrative support. 

Then the Academic bodies of medicine of virtually every major discipline have weighed in. These include the Association of American Colleges, Family Medicine, Internal Medicine, Pediatrics and Osteopathy. Medscape a site that provides information to the profession reports that the American Public Health Association put forward that the bill would jeopardize the health and lives of millions of America people. They point to the eradication of a key component of the ACA that provides twelve percent of the funding for the Center of Disease Control and Prevention, is dropped. 

So from both ends of the political spectrum there are the flood of lobbyists and activists that are against the bill and none on the record as supporting it.

THE POTUS

Trump after initially being blasé about the whole process has committed himself holus bolus to the Ryan endeavor. In supporting the AHCA he has broken a key campaign pledge to increase medical coverage to every American, making it more affordable and of a higher standard. (This type of betrayal doesn’t worry The Donald because when the time comes he will go into the bullshit mode and lie his way around it). His stated objective is to persuade the conservative non believers to go along with the AHCA in what will be a crucial test for his Presidency. If he can’t pull the Party together he will have failed as its leader. While the velcro Trump has proved everyone wrong time and again, he seems to have his work cut out this time. However he is already tweeting that if the bill doesn’t pass it will be the Democrats fault!

The fact that the Republican Congressional leaders of the “repeal only” group have already come out in opposition rather than wait to negotiate and speak with Trump does not augur well for his ability to persuade them to go along for the greater good of the Party. Maybe he wasn’t around for the Tea Party takeover of the GOP. They got in before him and they have enough votes to dictate the direction of the Republican Party. Ask former House Speaker Boehner who lived through it all till his position became untenable. He has predicted that repeal and replacement is not going to happen.

AT THE END OF THE DAY

For Trump the defeat would be a major set back which will put him on a path of tweeting and accusing. He owns it whether he likes it or not. It is not for nothing that the Democrats insist on calling the AHCA, “Trumpcare”. Who knows what pressure he will apply to “Seal the Deal”.

If the bill fails the deficiencies of Obamacare must be immediately addressed. In a sane world it would also present an opportunity to revamp the most costly inefficient healthcare service in the world. It chews up one out of every six dollars, sixteen percent of GDP, far more than in comparative countries. The administrative costs are an unholy thirty percent of that total - about a trillion dollars. Hospital and Health System CEO’S earn millions. Health care costs are the commonest cause of individual bankruptcy. Ironically more and more of those who can afford it leave the country for elective medical procedures. There is an incredible imbalance in the distribution of medical specialties making the country dependent on internationally trained doctors to fill in the gap for Primary Care and rural services. (This would be exacerbated in Planned Parenthood got the chop). Trump’s projected Muslim ban left a big gap in some Residency Programs even though it involved only a few Middle East countries.  Malpractice litigation increases costs dramatically as Doctors practice defensive medicine ordering test after test. Just to highlight some of the issues. 


Ironically, Hillary Clinton’s 1990’s plan came the closest to addressing the American health care problem that involves educational institutions as well. 

Monday, March 6, 2017

TRUMP: WHY LIE ABOUT OBAMA?












Donald Trump after a brief break from lying, ( The Washington Post Fact Checker noted that for the first time in memory it didn’t have to fact check Trump for a whole twenty - four hour period), tweeted that Barack Obama,“Bad or Sick Guy”, personally ordered a wiretap on Trump Towers. He wailed McCarthyism, Nixon/Watergate and “Tapp, (sic), during very sacred election process”. The next day he followed it up demanding an enquiry into Obama's alleged felony.

Why would he do something so outrageous and easily provable as that lie? The answer is simple - it suddenly halted the discussion on the Trump Russian connection. 

TRUMP’S DIVERSIONARY TACTIC - OBAMA BUGGED TRUMP TOWERS!

Trump knows the conventional media still don’t know how to handle his unashamed lying as the Sunday talk shows proved. Their discussions ranged from outright shock, to how to prove Trump wrong, to whether it was justifiable to ouright call this garbage lies. “Maybe one should wait and see?”,  “Are the FBI entitled to acknowledge this?” or “How does one know that he doesn’t really believe it?” were common contributions to the Trump debate. Then the politicians promised to investigate and Lindsey Graham threatened that the world would come to an end if Obama indeed did do this. Some Republicans in Congress want to send this matter to the Intelligence Committees. In fairness the consensus among the sane is that Trump has gone off the rails.

Trump also knows that his base will believe it or at least agree on the Obama probe. To the fawning sane around him he can always grudgingly concede much later, “Barack Obama didn’t wire tap me - period”. Some in the press will  then herald this as a sign that the much awaited transformation in the POTUS has finally begun, again!

The fact that the former Director of Intelligence James Clapper has categorically denied that the Intelligence Agencies that he oversaw did not wiretap Donald Trump nor did the FBI seek a warrant to do so will not put a stop to this madness. In a futile last ditch effort to save the President from himself FBI Director Comey asked the Justice Department to reassure Trump that there had been no wire tap. However Trump may rant there is no reason that Jay H. Ell will be sidetracked. So onto the real deal - Russia.

WHERE WERE WE MARCH 2? OH YES IN RUSSIA

So let us get back to the Russian connection which amongst all the chaos surrounding Trump stands out. Let us get back to where the debate was on March the Second following the revelation that yet another member of the Trump camp, the Chief Cop to be, Jeff Sessions, at his confirmation hearing as Attorney General had lied, or should Jay H. Ell say misspoke.  He initially claimed that he had had no conversations with the Russian Ambassador. His explanations as to why he waited for the Washington Post to jog his memory before recalling the meetings with Putin's representative were facile. He had extremely good recall in some areas of the interactions but where it mattered no recollection whatsoever. He claimed he  had met the Russian Ambassador at the Trump Republican Convention as a Senate Member of the Armed Committee although the Senate account is not where his expenses for the meeting were paid from.

But Sessions is just one more strand in what is building up to be scandal of monumental proportions. At least he had the good grace to kinda recuse himself from some of the possible related investigations. This as opposed to resigning and having himself charged with perjury.

THE RUSSIAN CONNECTION

  • It is incontrovertible that Russia hacked, spread false news and the like in an attempt to subvert the American Electoral Process. Let that sink in - seventeen American Intelligence Agencies came to that conclusion and Obama instituted sanctions as a result. They didn’t wage conventional war to change the political process or influence hearts and minds in America they waged cyber warfare. They didn’t physically break into the Democratic National Committee’s headquarters, they hacked it electronically. John McCain has outright called the Putin behavior an act of war. The Russian Tzar did this with two objectives in mind - to weaken the American Democratic Process and to favor one candidate over another, namely Donald J. Trump. 
  • It is fair to say that Russia and America, while not in a declared war are at opposite sides of the world political divide. Without going into too much detail Russia are threatening NATO, America’s major military alliance. Most recently they invaded Ukraine, a country that desires to join NATO, and seized Crimea which is a strategic chunk of the Ukraine. As a result America initiated sanctions. Putin and Obama have been on opposite sides in the Syrian Civil War - the former backing the dictator Assad and America supporting the rebel factions. 
  • In his campaign, while the ongoing hacking and release of documents to Wikileaks was going on Trump praised and supported Putin. The Donald even called on Putin to hack Hillary’s e mails. Trump denied to the bitter end of the campaign that it was Putin that was behind the hacking. He cheerfully used the Wikileaks releases, that have been credibly linked to Putin, to attack Clinton mercilessly. In short Trump capitilized on Putin's actions.
  • A thirty five page dossier on the Trump Russian connection surfaced which the US Intelligence Services found credible enough to warn both Trump and Obama about. The purpose of the warning was that it contained material that could potentially be used as blackmail against Trump. The high power US intelligence delegation maintained that Trump was at risk of being blackmailed as a result of its salacious contents which detailed behavior and financial allegations. It was compiled by a Christopher Steele a former British MI - 6 agent. The agent is well known to the FBI who offered to pay Steele to continue with his investigation. The FBI have utilized Steele’s services in the FIFA corruption scandal and is regarded as "credible".
  • The dossier contained, as yet, uncorroborated explosive material as to the motivation of Russian behavior in their support of tilting the US election in favor Trump. The report alleges that that the Russians believed that had material to blackmail Trump into their bidding.
Arising out of all this is the question as to whether Trump colluded in any of the Russian activity.  An assertion that he vigorously denies. In fact it would constitute treason at the highest and impeachment at the lowest if he had. This charge cannot be confirmed or denied without an exhaustive impartial investigation. As matters stand the evidence at best is circumstantial.

TRUMP AND HIS CAMPAIGN’S STRANGE RELATIONSHIP WITH PUTIN AND RUSSIA

Trump.

It is fair comment that Trump has done nothing to disabuse conspiracy theorists that he is in this up to his neck. He has given so many different stories as to whether he has met Putin or not that it is quite a hoot to watch them being played over and over on TV. He has gone and on as to how wonderful Putin in and how “nice” it would be if America and Russians had good relations. In spite of denials of financial involvement in Russia his son is on record as saying that the Trump organization does a disproportionate amount of business with Russia. 

He has known relationships with Russian oligarchs which he denies. He had documented relationships with a Felix Later who Trump claimed at a deposition that he barely knows him. Felix Later connected him, according to Forbes, with several other oligarchs. More recently courtesy of Russian oligarch, Dmitri Rybolovlev The Donald more than doubled his money within two years when the Rybolovlev paid him ninety - five million dollars for a home in Florida that the Russian has never seen. A report on The Rachel Madow Show put Rybolovlev’s airplane, on a number of occasions, at the same time and place as Trump's as the latter darts around America. The rumor being that old Dmitri is the conduit to Vladimir.

Other stories abound about of Russian business connections.

Trump Campaign Team And Administration

The fact is that Trump’s campaign is littered with operatives that have had extensive contact with Russia and even Putin. (Blog: Trump: Nixon on Steroids - Russiagate?“) With monotonous regularity comrades have fallen off the Trump wagon as a result of their affiliation with Mother Russia, From Paul Mannafort, his partner Roger Stone and Carter Page to Mike Flynn, his former Chief Security Advisor they have all bitten the dust. More significantly there are three Cabinet members with significant ties to Russia. The Secretary of State Tillerson, former CEO of EXON, who has done deals directly with Russia, has opposed sanctions and has been awarded The Friend of Russia medal from Putin himself. Jeff Sessions, his Attorney General most recently had his cover blown when his memory improved for him to recollect meetings with the Russian Ambassador. 

Then there is Wilbur Ross the Secretary of Commerce who is Vice President of the Bank of Cyprus. The other Vice President is a Russian oligarch. The recently appointed CEO of Cyprus Bank is a former disgraced head of the Deutsche Bank. The Deutsche Bank paid a $7.2 billion fine for Russian money laundering. The Bank of Cyprus is the bank where the Russian oligarchs are thought to do most of their money laundering. Bloomberg reported that the Donald owes the Deutsche Bank $300 million. This is one of Trump’s many conflicts of interest that don’t gain too much traction because he has so many other issues.

NOW WHAT?

Trump hasn’t done himself much of a favor by his unbelievably recklessly accusations. It did succeed in the short term, as it always does, in deflecting attention from the main issue - Russiagate. However he might have given the Republicans an out to conduct a wide reaching bi partisan investigation with subpoena powers. They can now agree to investigate both Obama and the Russian connection. They may even find a way to get at Trump’s taxes. He has to come out so badly whatever happens.

Needless to say other issues will hit the fan while Russiagate carries on of its own momentum. There is the retreaded travel ban executive order which however carefully crafted is sure to ignite protest and court challenges, the ACA repeal and replace has to be unveiled sooner or later…and so on. 

Only 199 weeks to go of the Trump Presidency.